Skip to main content

Self-management societies vs anarcho-capitalism: The new global war of ideologies?

by system failure

The last global economic crisis has brought the Left as well as the extreme nationalism in the front line. The rise of the Left in Greece and elsewhere came as an answer to the corrosion of the European Socialism and its absorption from neoliberalism. Current government coalition in Greece consisting from the two parties in power for the last 40 years, the right-wing, now neoliberal, party Nea Dimokratia and the "Socialist" party PASOK, is the best proof of this fact. Despite the fact that the rise of the Left and extreme nationalism creates a new front of intense ideological conflict, this is not something which prevents the dissolving of the old ideological lines.

Therefore, we are now in a period where the old ideological lines are blurring, and various conflicts cannot prevent this fact. This is something which has to do mainly with the fail of the Left to construct a new autonomous language relieved from capitalistic terms, and the full capitulate of the Right to neoliberalism, leading to the "mashing" of traditional ideologies and the prevail of a cultural totalitarianism which spreads in the West and elsewhere.

However, the brutality and the immediacy with which neoliberalism currently expands even in the most developed countries of the West, has not contributed to the emergence of revolutions with the classical form of the past, but it seems that leads societies in gradually rebuild the base of some principles and values which were declined heavily under the highly “economistic” nature of the dominant socio-political model of the last two decades or more.

Bringing back the lost concepts

Only a decade ago, or less, anyone who was speaking about concepts such as collectivism or solidarity in Greece, would be considered at least naive and would be treated with cynicism by the established culture of the extreme individualism. The bubble economy and bank lending which dominated particularly the early 90s and onwards, as well as the corresponding life-style, buried such concepts, buying the majority of people with overdoses of artificial prosperity.

So, while we are in a phase where the old ideological lines fade, and seems that there is a cultural totalitarianism which prevails more and more and has no opponent, the problems created by neoliberalism and the brutality with which prevails, as takes back this artificial prosperity, activate some hidden reflexes of societies and bring back to the surface some concepts, which until a few years ago had ended up being treated nearly as taboos.

In earlier times, Greeks had inside their culture such concepts, which were manifested in their daily life through various practices, such as the exchange of agricultural products, particularly in the Greek countryside. Even today, the older who have memories of such practices, were able to maintain or restore them again, in response to the economic downturn currently experienced by the majority of citizens.

Perhaps this explains, to some extent, the fact that the last five years with the economic crisis, the attitude of Greeks has changed dramatically against such alternative forms of social coexistence, beyond the essential needs created by the crisis. The Greeks can exploit their tradition and change their lifestyle and social organization, but this is not something simple, as conditions shaped by the dominant sociopolitical model, make such a venture to look very hard.

An unequal fight in the new ideological arena

A new great ideological conflict appears that begins to emerge. It's this among alternative forms of social organization and the emerging anarcho-capitalism. The great ideological chasm between these two models comes from the fact that alternative forms of social organization - which can be expressed mainly through cooperative movements or communities and groups of self-management - have in the core of their philosophy the key concepts of collectivity and solidarity, concepts which are totally opposed to the radical individualism that lies in the core of anarcho-capitalism.

The fight between them looks unequal because anarcho-capitalism is actually the final stage of neoliberalism, which paves the way by all means. Also, the conditions that have been formed for decades with the massive urbanization and creation of gigantic urban centers as well as the culture of extreme consumerism, are key facts in favor of anarcho-capitalism and constitute a major obstacle to the dissemination and development of alternative forms of social organization.

In Greece of economic crisis, one can see clearly how unequal is this battle, as the financial elites have imposed legislative decisions that led in sweeping changes to labor rights and welfare state the last three years, affecting these sectors in great extent. On the contrary, the only attempt of a legislative decision in favor of undertaking and self-managing a bankrupt company from employees, was not even brought to parliament for voting.

Thus, SYRIZA's* initiative to pass a specific law that would allow the organization and management of the bankrupted chemical industry BIOME by the workers, stays so far at the fringe, and this is not a surprise because it would create a precedent and could lead to a domino effect of similar actions by employees in other bankrupt companies in the private sector, something which would be highly destructive for the plans of neoliberal dictatorship and anarcho-capitalism as its final stage.

Self-management or anarcho-capitalism?

While, therefore, neoliberalism dissolves the nation-state and although it seems that nothing can stop its final form which is anarcho-capitalism, a rival ideology begins to form (quite slowly though), which necessarily adjusted to the absence of the state-protector and takes form through self-management communities. Self-management communities can easily adjusted to the new facts because their ideological matrix contains as main feature the absence of state and government intervention too. So, we may indeed experiencing a shift of the old ideological lines to another direction.

Although it would be somewhat naive one to try to identify the origin of the new rival ideologies, many believe that anarcho-capitalism contains some theoretical ideas of early anarchists or radical individualists like Stirner and Kierkegaard. Self-management communities, on the other hand, lead to other theorists of anarchism, such as Godwin, Proudhon and Bakunin, who do not reject concepts like collectivism.

Anarcho-capitalism, however, actually borrows the concept of anarchy and uses it misleading. Thus, although anarcho-capitalism requires the state absence, does not mean that will be free from a global power core controlled by the big capital, which, in a seemingly fully deregulated market will continue to determine the rules of the game to its advantage, free from any "embarrassing" state intervention and therefore more powerful than ever. Thus, the concept of anarcho-capitalism is actually spurious because gives the illusion of complete freedom of individual activity, which however, only serves the interests of a global economic elite.

Self-management communities instead, do not favor a global centralized control of any kind because they can operate locally and autonomously, merely having some common values and common characteristics. The locality of the self-management communities is a great advantage as there are no large energy requirements due to scale, but also due to a culture of degrowth and restrictions on basic needs at an early stage. Thus, self-management communities are possible even for the poorest societies.

Thus, the logic of self-management communities is based on a more balanced relationship with the environment, unlike anarcho-capitalism, which is based on unrestrained growth and the continuous downgrade of the natural environment, which ultimately ends in an accelerated environmental destruction.

Another big difference is that the state presence in the case of self-management communities is not an obstacle, but rather, even in limited form under certain conditions, a facilitator in their evolution, and also is possible to support them actively and directly with some additional functions. Such examples can be found in Venezuela of Chavez, but even in Europe, where before economic crisis hit the green development, there were proposals at European level, like for example microgrids, i.e. small and flexible electricity distribution networks, ideal for renewable energy applications and communities of small populations.

Self-management communities have a flexibility also concerning their form. They can be formed by groups of workers at workplaces (BIOME, ERT), or by people in small-scale residential areas (towns, villages). The experiment of ERT in Greece (http://failedevolution.blogspot.gr/2013_06_01_archive.html) showed that the self-management is possible.

The big question is whether self-management communities will become a fact for the vast majority of people in order to prevent the nightmarish final victory of anarcho-capitalism. It is certain that neoliberal dictatorship will do everything to prevent the expansion of a wider movement of self-management, which may eventually lead to an effort of immediate and practical application of the new rival ideologies, which will lead in turn, in the relatively near future, in a major class warfare.


*SYRIZA is the Leftist party in opposition

Comments

  1. You strangely use the term anarcho-capitalism.
    The deregulated capitalism is accompanied by a fascist increasingly large police and "justice" of the imperialist countries;
    In France, for writing "fascist criminal" a coup of the UN can be fined € 31,000 for invasion of privacy. (Which will become € 43,000).
    If the purpose is "excessive" the cop or military makes you condemn referred. € 7000 (damages) plus € 24,000 'on call for not enelevé article).
    Rogue judges even take the trouble to give the appearance of legality.
    The bourgeois state privatize more of its tasks but is not an anarchist.
    The occupation of Iraq by the U.S. mercenary contract that is not anarchy, it's fascism.
    What happens and what Greece is a victim, it is a war that began in 1979, Thatcher gave the gong starting and accelerating: the war of the bourgeoisie against the formoisy.
    And which blocks the solution, it is the refusal of the Greek proto-formoisy to abandon its privièges. It reacts as Milyukovs in 1905. As graduates do not commit suicide as was asked to do Amilcar Cabral, there will be no solution. It should be an egalitarian party claiming € 1,000 for all Greeks aged 14 and € 500 per child in Greece.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for the comments. You are right, the worst is that the fascist police will be private in future.

      I actually agree with you, that's why I wrote in this article that "Anarcho-capitalism, however, actually borrows the concept of anarchy and uses it misleading. Thus, although anarcho-capitalism requires the state absence, does not mean that will be free from a global power core controlled by the big capital, which, in a seemingly fully deregulated market will continue to determine the rules of the game to its advantage, free from any "embarrassing" state intervention and therefore more powerful than ever. Thus, the concept of anarcho-capitalism is actually spurious because gives the illusion of complete freedom of individual activity, which however, only serves the interests of a global economic elite."

      The same happens with neoliberalism, in another article I wrote that "Inside this cultural totalitarianism, concepts have been distorted in such a degree that, today, in reality represent almost different things of what represented in the past. The concepts of "new" and "freedom" have been substantially annexed by neoliberalism. The result today, is exactly opposite of what these concepts supposed to represent in the past. The concept of "freedom" tend to mean the ability of economic activity in a global arena of fierce competition and nothing more. In order to prevail this model of primitive society simulation - the imposition, survival of the strongest - some human conquests of the past centuries dissolve, and this is propagated as the "new". The decline and the fight for survive regarded as progress." (http://failedevolution.blogspot.gr/2013/07/maggies-ghost-what-is-haunting-europe.html)

      Delete
    2. After my comments ..... I suddenly discover your LONG comment...
      I will translate it and answer..... tomorrow
      Thank you

      Delete
  2. Vous utilisez étrangement le terme d'anarcho-capitalisme.
    Le capitalisme dérégulé s'accompagne d'une fascisation de plus en plus grande de la police et de la "justice" des pays impérialistes;
    En France, pour avoir écrit "criminel fasciste" sur un putschiste de l'ONU on peut être condamné à payer 31000€ pour atteinte à la vie privée.(qui deviendront 43000€).
    Si le propos est "excessif" le flic ou le militaire vous fait condamner en référé. 7000€ (de dommages et intérêts) plus 24000€ 'd'astreinte pour ne pas avoir enelevé l'article).
    Les juges voyous ne se donnent même plus la peine de donner l'apparence de légalité.
    L'Etat bourgeois privatise de plus en plus de ses tâches mais n'a rien d'anarchiste.
    L'occupation de l'Irak par les mercenaires contractuels US ce n'est pas de l'anarchie, c'est du fascisme.
    Ce qui se passe et ce dont la Grèce est victime, c'est une guerre commencée en 1979, dont Thatcher donna le gong de départ et qui s'accélère : la guerre de la bourgeoisie contre la formoisie.
    Et ce qui bloque la solution, c'est le refus de la proto-formoisie grecque de renoncer à ses privièges. Elle réagit comme Milioukov en 1905. Tant que les diplômés ne se suicideront pas comme leur demandait de le faire Amilcar Cabral, il n'y aura pas de solution. Il faut en Grèce un parti égalitariste qui réclame 1000 € pour tous les Grecs à partir de 14 ans et 500€ par enfant.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Formoisie is a concept I have discovered in 1993
    I have put a definition on reverso Dictionary
    +++++
    http://dictionary.reverso.net/english-definition/formoisie
    formoisie n.
    (in neomarxist thought) the second main exploitive social class: The bourgeoisie of formation. The members of the formoisie have human capital, receive high wages (the most frequently thanks to their diplomas) and consume more than the world GDP. (neologism 1993 Yanick Toutain)
    [Hum. Sc.]The formoisie is the social class that created social-democracy and stalinism.

    First appearance of the neologism in "30 thesis for a pedagogical revolution" 1993

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, very interesting. I think Marcuse speaks about something similar in "The one-dimensional man".

      Delete
    2. Sorry
      I discover today your short answer.
      About Marcuse. I am a partisan of Wilhelm Reich (He always give me intellectual food) .... But I don't see what are the similar thesis of Marcuse and me.
      Please what do you call "something similar" ?

      Perhaps, I must READ again Marcuse (I didn't do since..... near 1980 )

      Delete
    3. Yanick, its nice to see you back. Marcuse uses a specific term for this class, I'm not sure if it is the same, but Marcuse belongs to the neomarxist Frankfurt school, so its not strange. I suggest that you should read again "The One-Dimensional Man", because it's very relevant with what's going on in our days.

      Delete
  4. Here is my article where I proove that anarchists and POUM in Spain were forming groups of 25 and choosed basis delegates 1/25
    El POUM y los anarquistas españoles formaron grupos de 25 con un delegado de la base (1/25). Nosotros debemos hacer lo mismo.
    If you translate my article in greek langage, I would put it on RevActu

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That would be very interesting but I'm afraid I don't know the Spanish language at all. If I find someone who does I'll give it a try. By the way, I'm a little bit puzzled since I think you write in French as well. Stay in touch.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Oct. 7 Reports Implode: Beheaded Babies, NY Times Scandal, & More

Glenn Greenwald    

Israel’s Descent Into Madness & the Holocaust Comparison

BreakThrough News   Rania Khalek was joined by Tarik Cyril Amar, a historian from Germany and associate professor at Koc University in Istanbul, to discuss Israel’s descent into genocidal fascism. Prof. Amar addresses whether it’s useful to make Holocaust and Nazi comparisons and the real reason behind the West’s unshakeable loyalty attitude when it comes to Israel’s barbarism.   

Zionist and US imperialist criminals are about to grab the natural gas off shore Gaza

globinfo freexchange   As the genocide against Palestinians of Gaza is about to be completed with an act of unprecedented brutality by the Zionists and butcher Netanyahu through the bombardment of about 1.4 million civilians in Rafah, it seems that they have already set their next primary goal. Which, in short, is to grab the natural gas resources off shore Gaza, together with their US imperialist buddies whose contribution to the genocide has been undoubtedly critical.     As already reported , in 2007, Hamas came to power and Israel launched an offensive on Gaza Strip, leaving behind 1,400 dead Palestinians, but taking with it the gas fields. Within a year, Israel announced the discovery of the Leviathan natural gas field, which did include Gaza's riches, valued at 453 billion dollars. But Gazans have been denied around 47 billion dollars in revenue. As for Tel Aviv, it's gunning to become a new hub. At that moment in time, that is 2022, Russian oil and gas were sanctioned.

Neocon Queen Victoria Nuland Ends Her Reign: Exposing a Catastrophic Career

Glenn Greenwald    

Τυχαία γεγονότα στην τριτοκοσμική μπανανία των Βαλκανίων

failed evolution   1) Συμβαίνει το μεγαλύτερο σιδηροδρομικό δυστύχημα στην ιστορία της χώρας. 2) Γίνεται αστραπιαία επιχείρηση μοντάζ των συνομιλιών του σταθμάρχη από μηχανισμό του καθεστώτος, πριν ακόμα φτάσει στα χέρια των αρχών, προκειμένου να αποδοθεί η τραγωδία αποκλειστικά σε ανθρώπινο λάθος και να βγουν από το κάδρο οι πολιτικές ευθύνες ανώτατων κυβερνητικών αξιωματούχων. 3) Αναπαράγεται το παραποιημένο υλικό αστραπιαία από ναυαρχίδα της καθεστωτικής προπαγάνδας. 4) Τοποθετείται επικεφαλής στην επιτροπή-παρωδία πρωτοπαλίκαρο του καθεστώτος Μητσοτάκη που εργάζονταν παλιά στην ίδια αυτή ναυαρχίδα. 5) Η επιτροπή κλείνει άρον-άρον την υπόθεση αποκλείοντας ουσιώδεις μάρτυρες που είχαν προειδοποιήσει επανειλημμένα τον αρμόδιο υπουργό για τον κίνδυνο μεγάλου δυστυχήματος. Σταματάει έτσι και η όποια σε βάθος διερεύνηση για την τσιμεντοποίηση του χώρου και την απόπειρα συγκάλυψης της τραγωδίας.  

Το σκάσιμο της φούσκας Μητσοτάκη με νέα επίσημη χρεοκοπία και οριστικό τέλος της μεταπολίτευσης

του system failure   Τα αποτελέσματα των εκλογών της 25ης Ιουνίου ήταν λίγο-πολύ αναμενόμενα όσον αφορά τις πρώτες θέσεις με βάση και τα αποτελέσματα της πρώτης κάλπης του Μαίου. Αν συμπεριλάβουμε και το ποσοστό της αναμενόμενης αποχής, δεν μας έδωσαν κάποια ιδιαίτερη έκπληξη. Αυτό όμως που φαίνεται να αιφνιδίασε ακόμα και το συστημικό κατεστημένο, είναι η είσοδος των δύο υπερσυντηρητικών, ακροδεξιών κομμάτων Νίκη και Σπαρτιάτες, με το τελευταίο να έχει ξεκάθαρες διασυνδέσεις με τον πρώην Χρυσαυγίτη, Ηλία Κασιδιάρη. Παρά τη μεγάλη νίκη Μητσοτάκη, οι μιντιακοί ινστρούχτορες της καθεστωτικής προπαγάνδας εμφανίστηκαν σε γενικές γραμμές "μουδιασμένοι" και αυτό οφείλεται στο γεγονός ότι το συστημικό κατεστημένο (δηλαδή τα μεγάλα οικονομικά συμφέροντα που ελέγχουν και το σύνολο των μεγάλων ΜΜΕ πανελλαδικής εμβέλειας), πέτυχε μόνο έναν από τους τέσσερις μεγάλους στόχους που είχε θέσει εξ'αρχής. Μιλώντας με ποδοσφαιρικούς όρους, ουσιαστικά έχασε με σκορ 3-1.   Ο μεγάλος στόχος πο

The Shadowy, Intelligence-Linked Group Driving the US Towards War With Iran

"United Against Nuclear Iran does not miss an opportunity to try to bring the United States closer to a military conflict with Iran. And on the other side of the equation, they also have worked very hard to oppose efforts to de-escalate the U.S.-Iran relationship."   by Alan Macleod   Part 7 - A Lesson From History   The history of Iran has been intimately intertwined with the United States since at least 1953 when Washington orchestrated a successful coup against Prime Minister Mohammad Mosaddegh. Mosaddegh had refused U.S. demands to stamp out Communist influences in his country and had nationalized the nation’s oil. The U.S. installed Shah Mohammad Reza Pahlavi as a puppet ruler. An unpopular and authoritarian ruler, the Shah was overthrown in the Revolution of 1979. Since then, it has become a target for regime change, and its nuclear program is something of an obsession in the West. Often orchestrated by UANI officials while they were in government, the U.S. has carried

How the CIA oversees the Ukraine proxy war on Russia

Geopolitical Economy Report   Several reports in mainstream US media outlets show how the CIA has helped to direct the proxy war against Russia in Ukraine, and played a role in causing the conflict in the first place. Ben Norton examines the evidence.   Related: Confirmed: US imperialists wanted to drag Russia into a war with Ukraine since at least 2019

Israel Carries Out Most Sadistic Massacre, Opens Fire On Gaza Aid Convoy

Richard Medhurst  

The real reason behind TikTok ban

Glenn Greenwald /  Richard Medhurst